Culture
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
The latest edition
Gathering the headlines…
Connecting you to stories from original sources.
Business · News article
A new business-friendly rule on worker classification just released today by the US Department of Labor promises to make it easier for businesses to work with contractors and could even expand contracting relationships into new roles. The Wage and Hour Division’s final rule updates how the agency will determine whether a worker is an independent contractor or employee under several federal laws, providing a simplified approach and reducing the confusion that has led to significant litigation over the past decade. Here’s everything you need to know about the final rule and four steps to take before it takes effect in mid-January.
Independent contractor relationships exist in almost every sector of the economy, from construction and design, to gig-work and goods transportation. But a hodgepodge of state laws, federal and district court rulings, and changing federal regulations have made it hard for businesses to discern when their staff is truly a contractor or a full employee.
The distinction is important because employees have various rights and protections that contractors don’t, like the minimum wage and workers’ compensation, among other benefits.
The new final rule sets out a new, but familiar, test to help guide employers on how to make the call between contractor and employee.
“Employers need to be certain which factors determine a classification decision before they commit to a workforce strategy,” said Dave Dorey, a partner in FP’s Washington, DC office. “By giving substantial weight to control over the work and the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss, this rule makes that assessment substantially more predictable. That is welcome news for employers, employees, and independent contractors alike after years of regulatory uncertainty.”
The test considers five factors when evaluating whether a worker is an employee or independent contractor in business for themselves. This analysis applies under multiple laws enforced by the DOL, including the Fair Labor Standards Act, the Family and Medical Leave Act and Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act, all of which use the term “employ.” Keep in mind, the rule doesn’t impact worker classification under other laws, like federal tax code or state and local laws, so work with your FP counsel to understand the full scope of your obligations.
Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling billed the final rule as providing certainty after years or regulatory ping pong during a ceremony at the DOL’s headquarters in Washington, DC November 19. “We are putting an end to this regulatory confusion.” DOL officials say that the clarity offered by the rule could encourage businesses to engage with independent contractors more, and in roles they previously didn’t hold.
The final rule sets out an economic realities test – commonly used by courts to determine worker classification – that looks at whether a worker is economically dependent on a potential employer for work, or is a contractor in business for themselves.
The test sets out two core factors, placing greater weight on:
the nature and degree of the individual’s control over the work; and
their opportunity for profit or loss based on initiative or investment.
If a worker’s status isn’t clear based on those two core factors, the final rule says businesses should look to:
the amount of skill required for the work;
the degree of permanence of the working relationship; and
whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production.
When evaluating the individual’s economic dependence on the potential employer, the final rule emphasizes that “the actual practices” of the worker and the business are more relevant than what may be contractually or theoretically possible.
The final version of the rule is nearly identical to the version proposed in February. The public submitted more than 16,500 comments on the proposal, which the DOL addressed in the final rulemaking. Read our prior coverage of the proposal here.
The DOL lays out 14 examples of how to apply the factors outlined in the test, but keep in mind these only demonstrate which classification a particular factor supports—not necessarily the final call on their classification status. Here’s a few of the scenarios included in the rulemaking:
Example: A truck driver who runs deliveries for a logistics company, but owns and operates their own truck. The logistics company requires the driver to comply with federally-mandated transportation safety drug and alcohol testing and to meet certain contractually agreed-upon delivery deadlines. The contract includes incentives and penalties for meeting the deadlines.
Finding: The driver controls the important parts of her work, which points toward independent contractor status. Even if the logistics company requires testing or sets deadlines, that concerns legal compliance and commonplace contractual commitments rather than indicating control.
Example: A construction worker starts a job without roofing skills. Over time with the company, the worker receives training and develops these skills.
Finding: This scenario points towards employee status. The job didn’t require a specialized skill, and the worker relied on the company for training. Becoming skilled through company training does not change the result in this example.
Example: A roofer is hired by a construction company for existing roofing expertise and receives no training for this work. The worker relies on advertising his roofing skills to secure work from this company and others.
Finding: This factor points towards independent contractor status because the worker has specialized roofing skills. Using those skills to attract customers may also matter separately when evaluating business initiative.
Example: A part-time editor for a digital news outlet works from home. Their duties include assigning, editing, writing, and scheduling articles for the outlet’s website while coordinating with full-time employee editors.
Finding: This points toward employee status because the editor participates in the outlet’s entire overall production process, and completes the same work as other employees. Working part-time or remotely does not outweigh that involvement.
The rule will go into effect 60 days after it is officially published in the Federal Register, which is expected over the next few days. But, it could face a bumpy path forward.
Opponents of the regulation, like unions and worker advocates who say it isn’t protective enough of workers, could challenge it in court.
The new Democratic majority in Congress may have ammunition to pass new legislation, like the Protecting the Right to Organize Act, that would supersede the rule.
Democrats could use the budget process to block funding for enforcement of the rule.
As we await the official implementation date of the new rule in mid-January, you should consider the following four steps.
1. Review your current work arrangements and consider how the changes will impact your business model.
2. Review state rules to ensure you’re still in compliance. Many states have stricter independent contractor standards than the federal level. You will still need to ensure your work arrangements comply with those rules, despite the more lenient federal rule.
3. Update current policies and train hiring managers if needed. Be sure that managers discuss the project and worker classification with HR or inside counsel before seeking freelancers, gig workers, or other independent contractors.
4. Consult with legal counsel if you’re uncertain about how the new federal proposal could impact your operations. Your FP attorney can assist you in auditing your wage and hour practices and developing a plan of action in response to the new rule.